CANADA – 2025/09/24: In this photo illustration, the Lithium Americas Corp. logo is seen displayed on a smartphone screen. (Photo Illustration by Thomas Fuller/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Lithium Americas (NYSE:LAC) has quickly emerged as one of Wall Street’s most exciting narratives. The stock has risen more than 100% over the last month, driven by an influx of optimism regarding U.S. lithium policy, government support, and increasing confidence in its key Thacker Pass project. For a company that spent a significant portion of the previous year in obscurity, this surge has been truly extraordinary — prompting investors to ponder a new question: after more than doubling, could LAC potentially double again?
However, if you are looking for growth with less volatility than holding a single stock, consider the High Quality Portfolio. It has consistently outperformed its benchmark—a mix of the S&P 500, Russell, and S&P MidCap indexes—and has generated returns exceeding 105% since inception. Collectively, HQ Portfolio stocks delivered superior returns with lower risk compared to the benchmark index; resulting in a smoother investment experience, as highlighted in HQ Portfolio performance metrics. In addition, take a look at What’s Next for Navitas Semiconductor Stock?
From Policy Buzz to Market Frenzy
The rally commenced after news emerged that the U.S. government is considering a minority equity investment in Lithium Americas as part of its initiative to secure critical minerals. This potential support, along with renewed progress on the company’s $2.26 billion Department of Energy loan, fundamentally altered how investors perceive the stock. Thacker Pass — LAC’s enormous lithium project in Nevada — is one of the largest identified lithium resources in North America, and federal backing would mitigate the financing risks while establishing the U.S. as a significant player in the global battery supply chain.
Investor sentiment shifted almost instantly. What was previously viewed as a long-shot development play quickly began trading as a strategic national asset. Lithium spot prices have also rebounded, electric vehicle demand remains robust, and the political emphasis on domestic supply independence has provided the sector with a substantial tailwind. This blend of government attention, macro momentum, and speculative excitement has driven LAC’s rapid ascent.
Can It Really Double Again? The Math Says It’s Possible
At approximately $7 per share and a market capitalization close to $1.7 billion, Lithium Americas is no longer considered inexpensive, but the rationale for further growth is clear if the company follows through. The first stage of Thacker Pass aims to produce around 40,000 tonnes of lithium carbonate equivalent (LCE) annually. At current market rates of approximately $20,000 per tonne, that output could yield roughly $800 million in yearly revenue once it is fully operational.
MORE FOR YOU
If operating margins eventually reach 25%, that results in about $200 million in annual profit. Applying a moderate 20× earnings multiple, which aligns with other clean-energy growth opportunities, suggests a potential valuation close to $4 billion — or roughly $14–$16 per share. That essentially represents a doubling from current levels. The calculations are not based on extreme assumptions — they present a realistic “success case” if the project progresses smoothly, lithium prices stay strong, and dilution is minimized.
In summary, the market is wagering that Lithium Americas can evolve from being a story stock into a cash-flow-generating domestic producer in the coming years. If that occurs, the stock could indeed see its valuation increase — but the margin for error is narrow.
Why Investors Are Paying Attention
On top of the numbers, there’s a compelling narrative at work. The concept of a U.S.-based lithium mine supported by federal financing aligns perfectly with the current strategic themes that captivate markets. For years, the U.S. has fallen behind China, Australia, and South America in establishing lithium supply chains. A fully funded, government-backed Thacker Pass project could alter that landscape. This situation is no longer solely about a mining company — it’s intertwined with energy independence, national policy, and the future of electric vehicles.
That’s why the stock has witnessed such heightened momentum: institutional investors, retail traders, and speculative capital are all rallying around a singular idea — that LAC could emerge as the first major American lithium producer at scale.
The Catch: Execution, Prices, and Patience
Yet, amidst all the enthusiasm, substantial risks remain. The DOE loan has not yet been finalized, and any shifts in political priorities or financing conditions could postpone or derail the agreement. The project itself is intricate, necessitating billions in initial capital, careful environmental management, and years of construction before production can commence. In mining, timelines frequently slip, and any delays can diminish market confidence.
Lithium prices also represent another major variable. The profitability that makes Thacker Pass appealing at $20,000 per tonne could diminish significantly if a global oversupply drives prices back toward $10,000. Additionally, Lithium Americas may still need to secure more capital, which could lead to further dilution of existing shareholders. After experiencing a threefold increase, investors will have limited tolerance for unexpected developments.
The Bottom Line
Lithium Americas’ extraordinary rally reflects the market’s conviction that it has transcended being just a small mining developer — it has become a cornerstone of America’s clean-energy aspirations. The stock is now viewed as a leveraged bet on U.S. policy, momentum in energy transition, and lithium’s long-term significance to the EV supply chain.
Could it double again? Mathematically, yes — if Thacker Pass operates as intended and the government financing materializes, a $4 billion valuation is attainable. However, the path to that goal is fraught with challenges, and any misstep could lead to a significant decline in the stock price. For the time being, LAC remains a high-risk, high-reward opportunity at the intersection of policy, mining, and the clean-energy future.
Now, we apply a risk assessment framework while constructing the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio, which, with a collection of 30 stocks, has a track record of comfortably outperforming the S&P 500 over the last 4-year period —and has achieved returns exceeding 105% since its inception. . Why is that? As a group, HQ Portfolio stocks provided better returns with less risk versus the benchmark index; less of a roller-coaster ride as evident in HQ Portfolio performance metrics.